I met a girl at a party who had the same name as my mother (a rare name.) I didn’t think much of it… Fast forward one year, and she and I are dating.
I meet her parents, and her dad swears he’s “met me” before. A few days later, my girlfriend, dumbfounded, reveals, “So, I know why my dad thinks you look familiar. Turns out, he dated your mom in high school, and he had named ME after HER!”